Trinity Western University wins Nova Scotia case

Law society won't appeal the decision
By Deborah Gyapong
Special to The B.C. Catholic

Caption: Amy Robertson

The Nova Scotia Barristers' Society announced Aug. 15 it would not appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada a recent court decision regarding Trinity Western University.

Trinity Western University, a private evangelical Christian university in Langley, welcomed the news.

"We're pleased that the Nova Scotia Barristers' Society is going to honour the court's decision," said TWU spokeswoman Amy Robertson in an email. "As Justice Campbell affirmed, the freedom to believe in God - or not - and practise accordingly is a vital right not just for faith communities, but all Canadians. This is an important step in maintaining that freedom."

On July 26 the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal ruled the society did not have the jurisdiction to govern law schools outside the province, and therefore it must accredit future students of a proposed Trinity Western law school.

At issue is Trinity Western's community covenant that students and faculty must sign that includes an agreement to abstain from sexual activity outside traditional marriage. Many organizations, including the Catholic Civil Rights League and the Evangelical Fellowship of Canada have intervened in TWU cases because of the religious freedom implications.

In a news release, the Nova Scotia Barristers' Society said it had made the decision after receiving legal advice.

"The Society remains deeply committed to equity and diversity in Nova Scotia's legal profession," said President R. Daren Baxter. "These issues are clearly important to members of the profession and the public across the province. The Society will continue making it a priority to advance equality and diversity issues in the practice of law."

Trinity Western University is awaiting two more court decisions regarding its future law students being received at the bar of the Law Society of Upper Canada and the Law Society of British Columbia.

In B.C., TWU and the Law Society await an appeal court decision. In Ontario, Trinity Western lost at both the divisional and the appeal court levels.

On June 19, the Ontario Court of Appeal upheld the lower court's decision that ruled Ontario legislation gave the Ontario law society jurisdiction to not accredit Trinity Western's graduates based on its community covenant.

TWU has sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in the Ontario case. If it is successful, it will not be the first time the university has gone to the highest court to defend its religious freedom to organize itself as an evangelical Christian university.

TWU faced opposition from the B.C. Teachers' Federation when it set up a teachers' college, but in 2001 the Supreme Court of Canada ruled in favour of TWU, noting the beliefs associated with the community covenant were not proof of future discriminatory conduct.

The story on the original ruling in Nova Scotia can be viewed at bccatholic.ca.